Sounds

Where Hindi says aa, Gujarati says o

To a Hindi ear, Gujarati sounds like Hindi with the endings bent. The bends are regular: a handful of sound rules turn घोड़ा into ઘોડો, खाना into ખાવું and मित्र into મિત્ર, and each can be learned in a minute. Here are seven, including one of the places where the two languages part for good.


A Hindi speaker arriving in Vadodara hears something maddening: the sentences are almost intelligible, yet every word seems to end on the wrong sound. Hindi and Gujarati are sisters, the case Sisters, not strangers makes in full, and much of their core vocabulary is the same inherited word worn down two different ways. Wear is not random; it follows rules. Here are seven, each a swap you can apply on the spot.

The first is in the title. Where a Hindi masculine noun or adjective ends in -aa, Gujarati ends in -o. घोड़ा ghoda, horse, is ઘોડો ghodo. काला kaala, black, is કાળો kaalo. मीठा meetha, sweet, is મીઠો meetho. Both endings are the old masculine ending worn two ways. The feminine does not move: घोड़ी ghodi is ઘોડી ghodi, काली kaali is કાળી kaali. Adjectives agree as in Hindi, so काला घोड़ा kaala ghoda is કાળો ઘોડો kaalo ghodo. Hear a Gujarati word end in -o, try it with -aa, and a Hindi word usually appears.

The second rule concerns a gender Hindi no longer has. Sanskrit had three genders; Hindi merged the neuter away; Gujarati, like Marathi, kept it and marks it with a nasal ending, written ું and heard as a hum on a final u. This app spells it -u, as people type it, so listen for the hum the spelling leaves out. One root shows all three: છોકરો chhokro, boy, છોકરી chhokri, girl, છોકરું chhokru, child. कपड़ा kapda, cloth, is masculine; કપડું kapdu is neuter. पानी paani is masculine; પાણી paani is neuter, so ठंडा पानी thanda paani is ઠંડું પાણી thandu paani. बच्चा bachcha is masculine; બાળક baalak is neuter. Not every neuter hums: ઘર ghar and દૂધ doodh are neuter with nothing to show it. The rule: distrust your own gender for anything that is not a person or an animal, and treat a humming -u as a sure sign.

Third, listen for a heavier l. Gujarati has a letter Hindi lacks, ળ, a retroflex l. The usual account: an l between vowels tended to turn retroflex in the west; Gujarati and Marathi gave it a letter, Hindi kept plain l. So काला kaala is કાળો kaalo, फल phal, fruit, is ફળ phal, कमल kamal, lotus, is કમળ kamal. Where Prakrit had a double ll the plain letter stayed, so फूल phool is ફૂલ phool in both and बोलना bolna keeps its l in બોલવું bolvu. Do not stretch the rule to कागज़ kaagaz, paper, which comes out as કાગળ kaagal: that ળ answers a Persian z, not an old l, and how it got there is not settled.

Fourth, a vowel neither language writes. Both drop the short a that Sanskrit spelling leaves at the end of a word: घर and ઘર are both ghar, कमल and કમળ both stop on the consonant. After a conjunct, though, Gujarati keeps the vowel where Hindi does not. मित्र, friend, is mitr in a Hindi mouth and મિત્ર mitra in a Gujarati one. धर्म dharm is ધર્મ dharma, and कर्म karm is કર્મ karma. These are Sanskrit words taken whole, spelled identically in both scripts; the difference lives in the mouth. It holds after clusters ending in r, l, y, v or a nasal; a loan ending in a hard cluster stops short in both, દોસ્ત dost as much as दोस्त dost.

Fifth, the verbs. A Hindi infinitive ends in -naa; the Gujarati one ends in -vu, with the same nasal hum as the neuter. खाना khaana, to eat, is ખાવું khaavu. करना karna, to do, is કરવું karvu. लिखना likhna, to write, is લખવું lakhvu. जाना jaana, to go, is જવું javu, with the vowel shortened as well. Unlike ghodo and kaalo, this is a different ending altogether, not one worn two ways, so it must be learned rather than heard. Learn it first; it unlocks every verb at once.

Sixth, the copula, and here the rules stop. Hindi है hai and Gujarati છે chhe mean the same thing and, by the usual account, are not the same word: है is traced to Sanskrit asti, “is,” and છે to a Prakrit verb acchai, to be or to stay, whose own deeper source is not settled. It is one of several places where the two part outright, with the pronoun मैं main against હું hu and the possessive का ka against નો no. What transfers is the paradigm’s shape, which rhymes even where the root does not: हूँ hoon is છું chhu, है hai is છે chhe, हो ho is છો chho. The last is in the greeting everyone knows: કેમ છો kem chho, “how are you,” ends on the verb Hindi supplies with हो.

Seventh, a sound that is written but not said. Gujarati has murmured vowels: in many words the h between vowels is no longer said, only breathed into the vowel beside it, while the spelling keeps the હ. બહેન bahen, sister, is one breathy syllable. કહેવું kahevu, to say, and રહેવું rahevu, to stay, do the same, and so does શહેર shaher, city. Hindi speakers have a head start, since most already say बहन bahan as something like behen; Gujarati took the habit further and made it standard. This app’s reading guide writes them as spelled and leaves the breath to you.

None of this makes Gujarati understood. Genuinely different vocabulary stays different: किताब kitaab is ચોપડી chopdi, बेटा beta is દીકરો deekro, and no rule turns one into the other. What the seven rules do is smaller and more useful: they reclassify the strangeness. A word ending in -o, an adjective in a humming -u, a heavier l, a kept a after a cluster, a verb in -vu, a breath where an h should be: each is a Hindi word in Gujarati clothes, and once heard the pattern is hard to unhear. Corrections and counterexamples are welcome, and from Gujarati speakers doubly so.

Keep reading

Origins4 min

Sisters, not strangers

Hindi and Gujarati grew from one parent, and much of their core vocabulary is the same word worn down two different ways. So why can a Hindi speaker not simply follow Gujarati? What “sister” means exactly, why it is not the same as borrowing, why no date marks the parting, and how this app labels each pair.

Scripts4 min

The line that went missing

Take a Devanagari chart, rub out the bar along the top of every letter, and you are most of the way to reading Gujarati. The two scripts match nearly letter for letter, and the exceptions fit on one hand: a retroflex ળ Hindi never uses, a dotted row Gujarati never adopted, two letters for the open vowels of loans, and an r that will not take u the ordinary way. Here is the map, what is and is not known about how the line came off, and a plan for reading ભાષાઓ by the end of a weekend.

Contact4 min

A bazaar without a z

Hindi and Gujarati borrowed the same Persian and Arabic words, and a Hindi speaker will recognize nearly all of them. But Gujarati spelling never took the letters that came with the words, so the bazaar lost its z, saaf lost its f on paper, and paper itself came out with a letter Hindi does not have. How the words arrived, what happened to them at the door, and where the trail runs out.

Contact4 min

The key that came by sea

Turn a chaabi in Delhi or a chaavi in Rajkot and you are, by the standard account, saying a Portuguese word. Four centuries of Portuguese forts and ships on the Gujarat coast left both languages a layer of household words, some shared, some taken by only one sister, and a couple whose road nobody can trace. Then English arrived and the same thing began again, in each language’s own way.

All articles →
Bhashao
Hindi & Gujarati — every language is a bridge.
About the app